Sports PerformanceUncategorized

Can a Hypoxic Training Mask Improve Performance?

Don’t be afraid of that man wearing the mask on the treadmill next to you. Even though he looks like a cross between a burglar and Hannibal Lecter, he probably means you no harm. He’s wearing what’s known as an “altitude mask,” and despite your concerns, he’s wearing it for a far less frightening purpose: To perform better in some physical endeavor. Even if it’s just to crush his one mile time every week in the gym. 

Meet the “Training Mask”

The mask your neighbor adorns is a relatively newer product designed to mimic the effects of altitude while at sea level. It works by restricting airflow to its user, which is said (per the manufacturer) to strengthen respiratory muscles, and create hypoxemia (reduced blood oxygen levels), with the ultimate goal of enhanced performance.1

Competitive athletes have long sought after altitude exposure to gain an edge on their competition, and for good reason.2 Ascending to a higher elevation creates hypoxemia, which causes the body to produce more erythropoietin (EPO), and ultimately boosts work capacity through increased production of red blood cells.The mask does come with several valve caps that can be interchanged to adjust the altitude level, with options starting at 3,000 ft. and topping off at 18,000 ft.1

Hypoxemia from a Training Mask

The question remains: Is that guy on the neighboring treadmill getting any benefit from the creepy mask, or did he just throw away 80 bucks?

Despite limited research on the Training Mask, a study published last year suggests that it indeed performs as advertised, which is to say it simulates altitude for its user.4 Study methods involved five young, healthy males performing 20 minutes of treadmill exercise at 60% VO2max, wearing the Training Mask at three different elevation settings: 3,000 ft., 9,000 ft., and 15,000 ft. Investigators reported significant reductions in blood oxygen saturation (SpO2) in subjects exercising at the two higher elevations, clearly demonstrating a hypoxic response. Interestingly, no significant differences were found in hypoxemia between 9,000 ft. and 15,000 ft.

What may be a more significant finding of their study is the mechanism by which the mask was creating hypoxemia, which researchers said resulted from rebreathing expired CO2 trapped in the users’ masks. They also remarked that hypoxemia created by restricted airflow is a novel, and seemingly effective way to mimic altitude without ever traveling to higher elevation.4

Shedding more light on how the mask might affect performance measures is a Canadian study conducted at the Northern Alberta Institute of Technology (although less authoritative considering it’s only found published on the Training Mask’s company web site).The methods included a mixed group of 14 men and women who performed five high intensity (90-100% VO2max) cycling bouts twice a week for five weeks while wearing the Training Mask version 1.0 (the altitude setting was not mentioned in the write-up). Significant increases were found in ventilation (VE) and tidal volume (TD) for both men and women. The investigators suggest that the Training Mask strengthened the subjects’ respiratory muscles, which they extended to probable enhancements in VO2max. Increases in power output were also observed, however only significantly in male subjects.5

Mask Users Love It. Especially NASM Master Trainer Karl Sterling

With such limited research available on the Training Mask, it’s difficult to objectively remark on its benefit or lack thereof. What is undeniable are the positive reviews it’s getting by regular wearers. Aside from its mostly five-star reviews on Amazon, the Training Mask has made a sizable impact on one of NASM’s own Master Trainers, Karl Sterling, who’s been wearing his religiously since his kids bought him one this past Father’s Day.

After seeing a few local athletes wearing it, Karl was intrigued by the mask but definitely didn’t take its use lightly. He asked his son, a medical student at Penn State University, to do a little digging on the mask to make sure it was a safe pursuit. After a year went by, Karl was surprised to receive the mask on Father’s Day, but was delighted since this meant his son approved for him to use it.

He started off slowly, wearing the mask at the 3,000 ft. setting just around the house, with very little exertion. Feeling fine, Karl decided to up the ante a bit and run one mile wearing the mask. From there he progressed his distance a little bit each week, but only as he felt ready. After one month of use, Karl was able to re-adjust his altitude setting to the next level, or 6,000 ft.

After about 4 months now of wearing his mask four times per week on average, Karl has worked his way to the top tier of 18,000 ft. He’ll typically wear it during endurance activities like running, but also keeps it on during resistance exercises performed in the same workout. 

Here’s what Karl loves most about his mask:

  • The challenge it imposes. He especially likes wearing it running up hills.
  • How strong he feels during workouts when he removes the mask after wearing it initially.
  • It forces him to pay more attention to his breathing – the cadence and depth of breath – which he believes increases his efficiency. He also notices his breathing now more often, outside of workouts.
  • In his short time using the Training Mask, Karl has no doubts about its performance-enhancing capabilities. In his words, “I was at a high level already, but now, watch out! It’s an amazing intervention.”

Karl’s advice for interested buyers:

  • If you purchase the mask, make sure you read the manual and start off slowly, such as wearing the mask around the house, doing light tasks before trying to run a 5K. You need to acclimate appropriately to avoid lightheadedness.
  • If you find that you’re in between mask sizes, wear the head strap so that your mask doesn’t rip (the manual states that the strap is optional).
  • If you’re thinking of getting a mask, consider doing regular (sea level) higher intensity cardio first if you’re just in “decent” cardiovascular condition. Karl considers the mask to be an advanced intervention for someone who’s already in good shape and wants to take their fitness to the next level.

With many rave reviews, it’ll be interesting to see both the development of the Training Mask, and emerging research in regards to its performance benefits.

  

References:

  1. Training mask 2.0. (2015). Training Mask. http://www.trainingmask.com/training-mask-2-0.
  1. Wilber, R. (2004). Altitude Training and Athletic Performance. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
  1. Brooks, G.A., Fahey, T.D., & Baldwin, K.M. (2005). Exercise Physiology: Human Bioenergenetics and Its Applications. New York, NY: McGraw Hill.
  1. Granados, J., Jansen, L., Harton, H., Gillum, T., Christmas, K., & Kuennen, M. (2014). “Elevation Training Mask” induces hypoxemia but uses a novel feedback signaling mechanism. International Journal of Exercise Science, 2(6), Abstract. http://digitalcommons.wku.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1865&context=ijesab.
  1. Dregar, R.W. & Paridis, S. (2013). Clinical study and technical report by NAIT University. Training Mask. http://www.trainingmask.co.uk/pages/clinical-study-training-mask-2-0.
Previous post

New Programming Ideas for Traditional Cardio Exercise, Part 2

Next post

5 Exercises to Combat the Negative Effects of Bad Posture

The Author

Jena Walther, MS

Jena Walther, MS

Jena Walther is an Exercise Physiologist at the Scripps Center for Executive Health in La Jolla, CA, where she performs fitness testing and provides health counseling for local, national, and global company executives. She is also an independent Personal Trainer, and Contributing Blogger for the app-based fitness company, Wildfire Life. In her career as a Trainer and Strength Coach, Jena specialized in creating elderly fitness programs for active and rehabilitating seniors, as well as corporate wellness initiatives, serving local companies such as Qualcomm and the National MS Society, Pacific South Coast Chapter. Jena received her Master’s Degree in Exercise Physiology from San Diego State University, and is a certified Health Fitness Specialist through the American College Sports Medicine.

3 Comments

  1. Erin James
    October 21, 2015 at 9:05 pm — Reply

    I would like to see a study completed with the mask to see subjects RBC count pre- and post-training for a minimum of 6 wks to see if the effects of using the mask create acclamation or acclimatization results at all, or it primarily is used to train the diaphragm.

  2. Rob
    October 28, 2015 at 9:56 am — Reply

    I’m pretty skeptical about the performance improvements that can be gained by wearing hypoxia mask since the research I’ve been exposed to indicates that in order for adaptation to occur (Incr EPO, Hb, plasma, vascularity, bicarbonate buffering system) at least 12 hours per day must be spent at altitude for approximately 3-7 days (the longer the better).

    “The investigators suggest that the Training Mask strengthened the subjects’ respiratory muscles, which they extended to probable enhancements in VO2max.”
    Ve or lung volume are not limiting factors of Vo2max, so while respiratory muscle strength may have improved, which could be tested with an EMG, it wouldn’t make much difference to Vo2max or performance.

  3. […] master trainers for the National Academy of Sports Medicine, Karl Sterling, provides some very helpful firsthand feedback about wearing and using a hypoxic training mask […]

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.