Newsletter

Diving Deeper into the Squat: Common Misconceptions

pes_regularTo this day, we still hear certain squat rules echoed over and over throughout gyms and health clubs by many fitness professionals that often sound contradictory. While some rules emerged through research, the origins of others may lie in folklore and myth. The squat is one such example where we hear an endless list of cues: keep the knees behind the toes, align your knees over your second toe, open your stance, keep your head up, and many more. Which do we trust as evidence-based and which present as more myth than fact?

Furthermore, when we watch a fitness professional squat, we oftentimes notice that many are incapable of squatting correctly on account of inadequate levels of mobility or stability throughout their kinetic chain (e.g., ankle mobility), they fail to follow their own rules and resort to compensated movement (dyskinesis), or need to update their knowledge and understanding of proper form given some updated research on human movement.

With that said, let’s examine some of these common squat rules:

  1. Keep your Knees Behind your Toes
  • Fry and colleagues examined squats where the knees moved or were restricted from moving forward. As expected, when forward knee movement was restricted, the shear forces and torques at the knee were reduced.
  • Shear forces at the knee involve anterior-posterior movement of bones at joint and affects cruciate ligaments most notably.
  • The anterior cruciate ligaments (ACL) begin to experience anterior shear forces starting at a 15° knee bend, experiences greatest anterior shear forces at a 30° knee bend, and then diminishes after a 60° knee bend.
  • The posterior cruciate ligaments (PCL) begin to experiences posterior shear forces at a 30° knee bend, experiences greatest posterior shear forces at a 60° knee bend, and then diminishes after a 90° knee bend.
  • Squatting beyond that depth increases compressive forces within the knee as the passive structures around the joint assume much of these forces, which unloads the cruciate ligaments in most people while also potentially decreasing compression forces on the menisci and articular cartilage in the joint.
  • However, the researchers also noticed greater amounts of shear forces and torque at the hips versus the knee when squatting without allowing the knees to move forward – the ramifications here are more serious given the fact that the lumbar spine is more susceptible to injury. In other words, more forward leaning at the hips because of forward knee restriction generates greater shear forces between the individual vertebrae in the spine (e.g., L5-S1, L5-L4, L4-L3, etc.). In other words, during the upward phase, more spinal extension is needed and this may be exacerbated by a head-up position. Keep in mind that for every 2° of extension of the spine from neutral, the compressive forces on the posterior annulus (the portion of the disc that resists pressure during compression) of each disc increases by an average of 16%.
  • The squat should be initiated by first driving the hips backwards (hinging) which:
  • Helps eccentrically load the gluteus maximus
  • Helps initiate an isometric contraction within hamstrings that help unload the ACL.
  • The knee only begins to translate forward at about 15 – 30° of hip flexion, creating more of a hinge joint at the knee which may reduce potential shear forces.
  1. Keep Knee Aligned over 2nd and/or 3rd Toes
  • The talocrural joint between the fibula, tibia and talus are more involved in plantar flexion and extension (i.e., mobility) whereas the talocalcaneal joint between the talus and calcaneus is more involved in postural stability, resisting inversion/eversion and pronation/supination. However, when the talocrural joint lacks mobility, the talocalcaneal joint contributes, thereby compromising its stability by pronating and everting. This often drives the knees inwards, increasing stress lines along the ACL. This is perhaps the biggest issue in the squat – limited ankle mobility
  • Be sure not to confuse slight foot eversion of 8-10° in standing position with neutral talocalcaneal position with eversion and pronation. Normal foot position is generally considered to be feet parallel to 8-10° of eversion.
  1. Open / Widen your Stance
  • A wide squat-stance is one where the feet are generally placed between 150 – 200 % of shoulder width.
  • Deep squats are popular given how they, coupled with a low bar rack position, can effectively target the gluteus maximus, adductors and hamstrings.
  • Outward rotation of the legs and feet often accompany the deep squat and is generally acceptable if the rotation occurs within the hip joint (i.e., femoral head), and not at the knee.
  • The more one rotates outward (i.e., 15 – 30° outward rotation), the greater the engagement from the adductors and the belief that the more powerful the squat becomes, but this position should never compromise good form. In other words, any limitations in adductor extensibility will become an issue during the deep phase and cause valgus knee collapse (inward knee collapse). Always maintain the knee alignment over the 2nd
  • Furthermore, excessive external femoral rotation (i.e., beyond 30 – 40°) might also change hip position – to accommodate external rotation of the femur, the pelvis tilts anteriorly which changes lumbar spine alignment and may even alter the body’s center of mass leading to a loss of stability.
  • Just stand and externally rotate your thighs and notice the tension build up in your low back. As mentioned previously, when un-racking the bar, the pelvis shifts naturally into a posterior tilt, forcing some anterior pelvic tilting due to leg position simply translates to more forces within the hip and lumbar spine.
  • By contrast, a narrow squat-stance is generally considered to be one where the feet are no wider than 120 % of shoulder width apart.
  • This position, coupled with higher bar rack positon, loads more into the anterior muscles.
  • This position also increases the potential for more forward knee movement.
  1. Maintain the Head-up Position
  • The head-up positon is probably a bad myth propagated in gyms. On one side, a head down position by as little as 4½° from neutral increases spinal flexibility, which in turn increases posterior spinal compression. Furthermore, it can diminish balance.
  • By contrast, a head up position is believed to help maintain balance and shift weight into the heels. More often than not, this is usually a consequence of inadequate hip flexor and/or ankle mobility that creates the forward trunk lean and necessitates a head-up position. As mentioned previously, this positon extends the thoracic spine and compressive forces along the entire spine.
  • Proper cueing is the maintenance of a rigid spine that is either neutral or slightly flattened.
  • This can be easily cued with a dowel keeping constant contact with the sacrum, thoracic spine and back of the head throughout the movement.
  • A slightly flattened spine is quite normal during squatting, especially with increased loads. As the bar is placed behind the line of gravity of the body, once un-racked the hips will naturally move forward (posterior tilt) to maintain center of gravity – this flattens the lumbar spine slightly.
  • Allow the tibia to translate forward, reposition the spine to be parallel with the tibia and the head will fall into a more neutral position.
  • Engaging your core and abdominal musculature during the squat can help prevent lumbar hyperextension that is so frequently observed. This muscle engagement can result in greater muscle activation than witnessed during a plank exercise – yes, your squats do target your abdominal muscles as stabilizers.

While some may argue that the squat is perhaps one of the most functional exercises we can do – that statement is not without controversy. While it does mimic a bend-and-lift movement, in life, that movement to pick up a box or child requires the hands to reach towards the floor and not be positioned with shoulder abduction and external rotation as in a back squat. Therefore, the traditional deadlift movement is the truly functional movement and should be taught first as a pre-requisite to the squat. Moving the arms into the back squat position requires thoracic extension that one may not have. The squat therefore, will compromise lumbar stability. Qualify your clients for the squat with a movement screen (i.e., moving the arms into the back squat position while observing lumbar stability) before teaching them the exercise. A movement should always precede an exercise. The depth of your squat should be dictated by a movement need (i.e., to get your fingers to the ground under a box) and not by an exercise (i.e., thighs parallel to the ground).

Although many variation of the squat exist, some truths will always prevail – maintain your knee/foot alignment, ensure hinging and timing of forward knee translation, facilitate adequate ankle mobility to avoid dysfunction, maintain a rigid pelvis (sacrum, thoracic spine and head) and aim to achieve parallel alignment between your tibia and trunk. With proper form, the likelihood of a repetitive-type injury reduces and performance improves.

 

For more on the squat, see NASM Essentials of Sports Performance Training 

References:

  1. Abelbeck KG, (2002). Biomechanical model and evaluation of a linear motion squat type exercise. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 16:516-524.
  2. Caterisano A, Moss RF, Pellinger TK, Woodruff K, Lewis VC, Booth W, and Khadra T, (2002). The effect of back squat depth on the EMG activity of 4 superficial hip and thigh muscles. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research; 16(3):428 – 432.
  3. Cook G and Jones B, (2007). Secrets of the Hip and Knee. www.functionalmovement.com
  4. Escamilla RF, (2001). Knee biomechanics of the dynamic squat exercise. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 33:127 – 141.
  5. Fry AC, Smith JC and Schilling BK, (2003). Effect of knee position on hip and knees torques during the barbell squat. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 17:629-633.
  6. Kanamori A, Woo SL, Ma CB, Zeminski J, Rudy TW, Li G, and Livesay GA (2000). The forces in the anterior cruciate ligament and knee kinematics during a simulated pivot shift test: A human cadaveric study using robotic technology. Arthroscopy, 16(6):633 – 639.
  7. Li G, Rudy TW, Sakane M, Kanamori A, Ma CB, and Woo SL (1999). The importance of quadriceps and hamstring muscle loading on knee kinematics and in-situ forces in the ACL. Journal of Biomechanics, 32(4):395 – 400.
  8. Markolf KL, Slauterbeck JL, Armstrong KL, Shapiro MM, and Finerman GA (1996). Effects of combined knee loadings on posterior cruciate ligament force generation. Journal of Orthopaedic Research, 14(4):633 – 638.
  9. Sakane M, Fox RJ, Woo SL, Livesay GA, Li G, and Fu FH, (1997). In situ forces in the anterior cruciate ligament and its bundles in response to anterior tibial loads. Journal of Orthopaedic Research, 15(2):285 – 293.

Previous post

Overcoming Rejection: When I Ask for a Sale and Someone Says “No”

Next post

Stress – How are you dealing with it?

The Author

Fabio Comana

Fabio Comana

Fabio Comana, M.A., M.S., is a faculty instructor at San Diego State University, and University of California, San Diego and the National Academy of Sports Medicine (NASM), and president of Genesis Wellness Group. Previously as an American Council on Exercise (ACE) exercise physiologist, he was the original creator of ACE’s IFT™ model and ACE’s live Personal Trainer educational workshops. Prior experiences include collegiate head coaching, university strength and conditioning coaching; and opening/managing clubs for Club One. An international presenter at multiple health and fitness events, he is also a spokesperson featured in multiple media outlets and an accomplished chapter and book author.

12 Comments

  1. Holly Ivey
    October 25, 2014 at 5:06 pm — Reply

    I can see how all of this makes sense theoretically, but to manage all of these alignment details is not only challenging when educating the client, but near impossible when monitoring yourself. Unless videotaping or having another very trained eye observe, the alignment gets distorted when doing a mirror check. One question:when cuing the knee placement behind the toes, often clients rock backward to compensate. Is this because of ankle dorsiflexion? And can it be addressed by placing a lift behind the heel?

    • October 25, 2014 at 11:33 pm — Reply

      Do you mean they have trouble balancing with that queue? I see that a lot and basically make them practice holding the squat form at the low position near something to hold onto for a balance check. It may also be that lay people have grown up being told not to stick their butt out (boys and girls), so it is something they have to get over. One of the most common queues I have to say to correct squats is “hips back first motion,” which clients don’t understand where their hips are so I end up modifying it by saying “stick your butt out more.” 🙂 It often corrects the issue of dropping the hips directly into the heels instead of behind the heels like they should go.

    • Ian
      October 26, 2014 at 2:23 am — Reply

      Hey Holly if you want a really good way to get these small things down pat and kind of systematic I recommend reading Becoming A Supple Leapord by Kelly Starrett. The book breaks down a lot of movements kind of systematically by position, by that I mean they tell you what position you need to get in/achieve, and gives you principles and strategies to get these things down 100% correct all the time. Also it is way easier to teach clients simple principles they can apply to get in good positions than these more in depth explanations. I’ve had a really awesome experience adding these things into my NASM education and the other way around. Supple Leapord wil help you organize all of it a lot better. In regards to your squatting question, I recommend box squats or placing a bench behind your client and telling them to aim for the bench or box. I would guess that the rocking backward that your seeing is just a motor control issue. By cuing them to aim their butt back they can get that hinge at the hip and their knees won’t travel forward until deeper in the squat. I say “keep your shins vertical and aim for the bench.” One tip for a NASM trainer is don’t think about muscle balance too much. There’s almost no way someones anterior tib is so active that their toes are coming up. I’d bet they’re just on their heels too much. Initiating that hip movement will solve that problem. Most things are solvable with motor control/cuing solutions then you can address muscle dynamics to help a client get into a better position. It’s all around easier to get them in the position then see how they’re body is solving mobility issues, going after those issues then seeing how it effects their squat position etc. We used to call that flexibility but now it’s just, “hey this is how you squat, this is a good squat position can you get in to it?” It’s yes or no then you go after what’s holding them back but you can get them squatting perfect (well at least really well anyway) from day 1 always focusing on improving their position through mobility/flexibility. Hope this helped. Peace and blessins’.

      • Bj
        October 28, 2014 at 5:24 pm — Reply

        Just make sure if you box squat, the client knows where the activation should be, not to rock, where the shin line is, and placement on the box. A touch and go is more corrective to the squat as opposed to an actual box squat.

  2. Stephen Dansevich
    October 28, 2014 at 3:59 am — Reply

    Unfortunately, the article ignores some important structural considerations (lever length relationships, hip socket depth/position, pelvic width, to name a few) that can significantly affect how & how well someone can squat, & that corrective exercises cannot address.

  3. […] reads for your Monday: Squat to your potential Prep and […]

  4. […] Diving Deeper into the Squat: Common Misconceptions […]

  5. July 21, 2016 at 11:00 pm — Reply

    […] and should be avoided. Although knee torque increases as tibial translation occurs, there is no evidence to support ones risk of injury is increased (Figure 8). (5) Conversely, if tibial translation is limited, an increase in trunk […]

  6. […] bagus untuk persalinan via blog.nasm.org […]

  7. […] bagus untuk persalinan via blog.nasm.org […]

  8. […] bagus untuk persalinan via blog.nasm.org […]

  9. […] The National Academy of Sports Medicine outlines these steps to performing the ideal squat: […]

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.